What went wrong?

The acting went wrong. The singing did not.

And what about the singing?

Did the producers honestly think there would be no backlash when audiences compared Julie Andrew’s British classically-trained voice to Carrie Underwood’s broad and brassy southern twang?

If we talk about Carrie’s voice, then that is what we get…..Carrie’s thick-cord, belt-like voice with it’s speech-like quality, wide vowels and all. What more can I say? It was exactly how I would have expected Carrie Underwood to sound singing The Sound of Music.